“Breastfeeding is awesome. Formula is awesome. Feeding your baby is awesome. Not awesome? Judgement.”
Amanda Seyfried–American Actress, model, and singer
The Role of Posture in bottle-feeding versus breast-feeding
Have you ever wondered why there’s such a big debate when it comes to bottle-feeding versus breast-feeding? After all, a correct feeding posture is a growing problem for mothers who want to either bottle feed or breast feed their infants. In this post I will examine the question, strictly from the point of having good posture, is breast-feeding better than bottle-feeding?
Here is the deal:
During breastfeeding a new mom will often hunch over to bring her breast to the baby, which can wreak havoc on the spine. Other concerns when feeding are holding the breast for the baby (compromising the wrist) and crossing the legs (causing pelvic and spinal imbalance).
But here’s the kicker:
Bottle- feeding poses big problems for babies that are not feeding in the correct posture. So what is the answer? The simple truth is that what works for one mom may not be viable for another. Once you decide which you prefer, you can than decide which posture problem to tackle. You will than be in a better position to answer the question is breast-feeding better than bottle feeding?
Let’s jump right in and look at the pros and cons of bottle-feeding versus breast-feeding
Gill Rapley, breastfeeding counsellor and lactation consultant and the former deputy director of Unicef’s Baby Friendly Initiative, has stated that breastfeeding education would mean…they are taking on staff who will implement ‘baby-friendly policies’.
By implication does this mean bottle feeding is not ‘ baby friendly’? Is a woman a less caring mother having bottle fed her baby?
One can find compelling evidence to contradict that notion.
The November 9, 2002, issue of the British Medical Journal revealed that “bottle-feeding was shown on television and in newspapers more frequently than breastfeeding and was presented as less problematic” (1)
Media Images May Deter Women from Breastfeeding
It gets more interesting when asking the question is breast-feeding better than bottle -feeding?
According to a major study in 2012 by The Medical Research Council, “Overall, breast and mixed-fed babies were rated by their mothers as having more challenging temperaments. Compared to formula-fed babies, breastfed babies showed greater distress, and were less likely to smile, laugh or vocalize. They were also slower to calm down following distress or excitement.” (2)
Based on the above information you won’t be surprised to find out that :
New mothers Increasingly moving toward bottle-feeding
This is what a 2016 study by the Indo Asian News Service (IANS) reports. It says, “An increasing number of new mothers are turning towards using expressed breast milk — either pumped or expressed by hand — instead of directly breast feeding their babies, a research has revealed.” (3)
So it’s settled right? You might be thinking that bottle-feeding is better than breast feeding. Hold on a moment. Consider the following:
Breast-feeding boost to babies IQ
According to a meta-analysis in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, “the IQ of breast-fed babies is up to five points higher than that of formula-fed babies, and the lion’s share of the benefit (around 3 points) seems to come from breast milk’s nutritive qualities, rather than from benefits in maternal bonding.” (4)
Want to know the best part?
More breastfeeding, less heart attacks
Sounds silly? It’s not. Let me explain. Studies at the University of Athens have shown that “ increasing breast-feeding time was reducing the risks of cardiovascular diseases”. (5)
In other words breastfeeding increases hormone levels to reduce the chances of mom’s vessels getting clogged up—-this means mom is less likely to suffer from hypertension or diabetes. If you want to know the odds, some say a reduction of about 20-50%.
For more information, feel free to read:
“Breast is Best.” Parenting magazines offer “23 Great Nursing Tips,” (http://www.parents.com/baby/breastfeeding/basics/breastfeeding-tips-from-moms/
The actual health benefits of breast-feeding are far thinner than most popular literature indicates. In a brilliant and engaging article, published in The Atlantic (2009), Hanna Rosin makes “the case against breast-feeding”. She examines the leading studies in the bottle-feeding versus Breast-feeding debate, and concludes that:
“The studies do not demonstrate a universal phenomenon, in which on method is superior to another in all instances,” concluded one of the first, and still one of the broadest, meta studies, in a 1984 issue of Pediatrics, “and they do not support making a mother feel that she is doing psychological harm to her child if she is unable or unwilling to breastfeed.” (5)
“I continue to breast-feed my new son some of the time—but I don’t do it slavishly. When I am out for the day working, or out with friends at night, he can have all the formula he wants, and I won’t give it a second thought.”— Hanna Rosin. She is the co-host of the NPR podcast Invisibilia with Alix Spiegel
So it all adds up to this. There are strong pro and cons when it comes to bottle-feeding versus breast-feeding. So take the next step, with everything you have read, and decide which will be your primary method for feeding your infant. Here are the challenges depending which method you choose. If you decide to bottle-feed, you will have to consider the proper posture of the baby.
Here are somethings that can happen when a baby is feeding in an incorrect posture:
- Bottle-feeding while lying back too far may cause choking, tooth decay, ear infection and tonsil infection.
- A baby can suffocate from liquid dripping into his or her mouth.
- Babies who fall asleep while bottle-feeding can draw liquid into their lungs ( and in extreme cases drown in their sleep). They might then choke or inhale food.
- Not lifting the bottle high enough may cause consumption of air, resulting in unwanted gases in the stomach. This will make a baby restless and even in some cases cause reflux, colic and diarrhea. (6)
What is needed and being worked on as we speak is an invention whose focus is “to provide a device that could fit onto a conventional baby bottle and monitor and alert when a baby’s feeding posture is incorrect.” (7)
This is huge because it means any mom can instantly know and not guess whether her baby is feeding posture is wrong.
It gets better:
Another object of a present invention which is being considered for a patent is “to provide a device that can notify a user when the baby is feeding in the correct posture.” (8)
So it all adds up to this: the future, most likely because of society increasing embrace of the working and busy mother, is promising very efficient ways of ensuring that her baby has correct feeding posture.
Here is the deal. Most new moms who are bottle-feeding are looking for a solution that will correct baby posture now. A solution that can take care of the posture problem of mom and baby is something I will end this post with.
We are talking about nursing pillows. Specifically pillows specially designed to support a baby’s head and body while breastfeeding or bottle feeding, and also to be used to support the baby while interacting with it in a variety of other activities.
Here is my recommendation:
My Brest Friend Original Nursing Pillow
I believe it covers the problems posed by bottle-feeding and breast-feeding in this post. As the manufacture puts it:
“The My Breast Friend nursing pillow is the perfect support pillow for proper latch-on and breastfeeding in comfort and security. The nursing pillow was developed in a laboratory of new moms, babies, and breastfeeding experts who set out to create a nursing pillow whose sole purpose was to answer all the needs of breastfeeding moms and babies.”
Product: My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow
Price: $ 34.99
Size: Product Dimensions
23.6 x 4.3 x 16.5 inches
Weight capacity: 1.54 pounds
Cheapest Place to Buy: Amazon
Warranty: Check with Company
Rating: 8 out of 10
Now it’s your turn. Want to have a peace of mind whether you bottle-feed or breast -feed? Go get My Brest Friend nursing pillow.
If You Like This Website Click Here To Create Your Own Website For Free
I like to hear from the readers so please leave me a comment below to let me know if this post helped you or if you have any questions
Amazon Affiliates Disclosure
Healthybacksupport.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com Certain images that appears on this site comes from Amazon Services LLC. Amazon. This content is provided ‘as is’ and is subject to change or removal at any time.
Henderson, CW. “Media Images May Deter Women From Breastfeeding.” Women’s Health Weekly, 23 Nov. 2006, p. 6
“New evidence adds to the breast versus bottle-feeding debate: UK research compares temperaments of babies fed by different methods.” Nursing Standard, vol. 26. no. 22, 2012
“New mothers increasingly moving toward bottle-feeding:Study.” IANS, 8 Dec. 2016
“Breast-feeding boost to babies IQ. “Nutraceuticals International, Nov. 1999.
“More Breastfeeding, less heart attacks,” Anadolu Agency, 5 July 2019
Rosin, Hanna. “The case Against Breast-Feeding.” The Atlantic, 23 Feb. 2009
2019 APR 19 (NewsRX)—By a News Reporter-Staff Editor at Health & Medicine Week — A patent application by the inventors
“A Device For Correct Feeding Posture” in Patent Application Approval Process (USPTO 20190096224) “Health & Medicine Week, 19 Apr. 2019, p. 9227
See note 7